Being Bimodal May 28, 2020 The five imperatives of all Quality Leaders Regardless of industry or company size, all Quality leaders share these five key imperatives. Arguably, I place product quality as paramount. In life sciences, more than any other industry, product efficacy is vital; does it do what it was designed to do? These two ensure patient safety, the ultimate accountability of the industry. Next comes continuity of supply of both existing and new product. Finally, compliance. I intentionally, and perhaps provocatively, put compliance last in this list. We know from data that a company can have a good compliance record but that may not necessarily be accompanied by good product quality, while the converse is frequently to be true: a company with good product quality tends to have that accompanied by a strong compliance performance. These five things core accountabilities are connected. The Quality Management System is called a system, not because it is executed in a software platform but because it is designed to be an interconnected, closed loop of processes that inform quality by design. Quality transfers that design into manufacturing, quality of manufacturing and supply all the way to patient. Then, from the patient back to continuous improvement of the initial design and manufacture, and ultimately through the end-of-life of that product. End-to-end quality management Product quality is complexThe quality of medical products is, of course, a complex topic. Simply put, it could be defined as a measure of how well that product meets established specifications and tolerances when tested against them. However, there are so many opportunities for quality events to effect product quality along the complex value chain, especially when we consider that value chain starts with ideation, discovery, design and development – and ends all the way out at the patient. Those specifications and tolerances have to be designed into the product. Quality By Design (QBD), Critical To Quality (CTQ) flow down: design for manufacture, supplier selection, raw material selection. All of these front-end aspects can affect product quality. Then imagine all the touch points on product, just on the factory floor alone: raw material incoming inspection, raw material storage, ordering, picking; manufacturing equipment calibration and performance; environmental controls, human intervention, finishing and packing, testing and release; shipping, distribution, storage, stability, and usage once product leaves the factory. These represent the countless opportunities for quality to be adversely affected. Compliance is still a challengeIt’s interesting that we still see so much priority given to complying with regulation over the other four of these imperatives. For me, compliance is just the ticket to the game. For many firms, compliance is still the number one goal of their quality organization. But if that’s the case, then the regulators have unintentionally created the opposite effect to that they set out to create. Their purpose is, and always has been, to promote and protect public health, not to cause manufactures regulatory nightmares. Talk to any of them today, and they will tell you that is true. I’ve discussed it just recently with several offices of the US FDA, and we were clearly aligned on that thinking. But let’s get real for a moment. The fact is that, while we should place compliance in its appropriate position of priority, it is a daily challenge for even those most mature of companies. Often large firms have some inspection taking place in some facility by some regulator, every single day of the year. Small and mid-size firms still struggle to meet even the basic requirements of increasing challenging and ever-changing regulation, so I don’t want to downplay the importance and significance of the problem. The FDA and other global regulators establish and enforce regulations to assure public health and patient safety. It can be difficult to feel it when you are a medical product manufacturing plant under inspection, there has clearly been a discernable rebalance on the part of most global regulatory agencies, as they became more risk-based in their approach. Bi-modality and the macro industry trends affecting qualityWhile these five things are front and center of the quality professional’s mind every hour of the day, increasingly over the past five years they are faced with a bi-modal challenge.Mode 1 is about operational stability, predictability, efficiency and incremental continuous improvement often characterized by the need to drive down Total Cost of Quality (TCoQ). Mode 1 is risk-averse and focused on prevention. Mode 1 can be seen as these micro challenges effecting quality.Mode 2 is exploratory. It is about innovative, creative out-of-the-box solutions. Mode 2 is about speed and big-step changes. It is risk-tolerant and proactive, where fast failure is allowed. Digital transformation and Industry 4.0 epitomize Mode 2.For Quality, Mode 2 can be characterized by seven macro industry trends: Process complexity and variability Pace of innovation Novel medical product Industry 4.0 Supply Chain Complexity Patient Centricity Total Cost of Quality (TCoQ) Continue to Shaping Proactive Quality About the author Stephen McCarthy is Vice President of Digital Innovation at Sparta Systems, acting as chief industry evangelist and customer advocate for Sparta. Steve has nearly three decades of experience as a quality and supply chain leader within the healthcare industry. Prior to joining Sparta, he held several high-profile positions within Johnson & Johnson, the most recent of which was as VP of Quality Systems Shared Services for their Pharmaceuticals, Medical Devices and Consumer sectors. His earlier career was spent in virology research at the University Hospital St. Thomas’ in London. He is a certified six-sigma process excellence black-belt as well as a certified 3rd degree black-belt karate instructor. Share via: Twitter LinkedIn Facebook Email
INFOGRAPHIC Automate and Visualize Batch Production | Elevate Efficiency and Quality TrackWise Experion Batch empowers Life Sciences manufacturers with advanced visualization, real-time data integration, and distributed batch control. Optimize productivity, ensure compliance, and maintain product quality with proactive decision-making and real-time alerts. Learn more
BROCHURE TrackWise Experion Batch DCS: Visualize Batch Production Like Never Before TrackWise Experion Batch combines Experion’s distributed control, batch automation, and unique visualization technology for a solution optimized for Pharmaceutical, Biopharmaceuticals, Medical Devices, and other batch applications. Learn more
EBOOK Three Strategies for Better Batch Visualization Discover how advanced batch visualization strategies can transform pharmaceutical manufacturing. Learn techniques to reduce cycle times, optimize efficiency, enhance troubleshooting, and minimize downtime through innovative process visualization solutions. Learn more
WHITE PAPER Leveraging Digitalization to Resolve Cell & Gene Therapy Manufacturing Challenges Life Science organizations are adopting modular facilities to speed up time-to-market and simplify product updates. Discover how modular automation and integrated platforms can optimize production, improve efficiency, and enhance compliance. Learn how to reduce integration time by 30-50% in this insightful whitepaper. Learn more
WHITE PAPER Increasing Manufacturing Flexibility with the Incremental Adoption of a Modular Platform Life Science organizations are adopting modular facilities to speed up time-to-market and simplify product updates. Discover how modular automation and integrated platforms can optimize production, improve efficiency, and enhance compliance. Learn how to reduce integration time by 30-50% in this insightful whitepaper. Learn more
WHITE PAPER Providing Enhanced Manufacturing Data to Contracting Companies: A CDMO Challenge and Opportunity Discover how the growing CMO and CDMO sector, projected to exceed $220 billion by 2023, can leverage data packs to enhance batch reports and critical insights. Learn about a platform-based approach to streamline data capture, meet client demands, and improve manufacturing efficiency. Learn more
WHITE PAPER Modular Automation: The Plug and Produce Opportunity for Life Sciences This whitepaper discusses the benefits of modular automation given the ongoing evolution to modular plants and what the industry dubs plug-and-produce processing. What standards should you be aware of as you make automation investments within the modular plant? How will modular technologies enable integration with component HMIs? What efficiency and cost impact can you expect to achieve? Learn more
WEBINAR Unifying Quality & Manufacturing – the Key to Optimizing Operational value Join industry experts Daniel Matlis, President & Founder of Axendia, Inc., and Steve McCarthy, VP of Industry & Business Development at Honeywell Life Sciences, as they discuss key trends and actionable strategies for unifying digital quality and manufacturing in the Life Sciences industry. Learn more
EVENT 2024 ISPE Pharma 4.0™ and Annex 1 Conference We're at ISPE Italy! Visit our booth to discover how we can help you accelerate your digital transformation journey. Learn more
EVENT BMWS Bio Manufacturing World Summit 2024 Join us at the Biomanufacturing World Summit to discover how our advanced life sciences manufacturing solutions can help enhance operational efficiency. Learn more
EVENT Pharma’s Digital Transformation: Navigating the Value Chain from development to Patient | PDA Italy Discover how a global CDMO drives digital transformation through the digitalization of multiple manufacturing plants using a Manufacturing Execution System. Learn more
ON-DEMAND Revolutionizing Recall Management in Life Sciences Recalls are expensive. They can impact public health and brand’s reputation very quickly. Watch this recent on-demand to learn new ways to address Product Recall challenges. We will discuss new ways an organization can potentially mitigate recall risks as well as how to leverage new innovative solutions to drive a more efficient and effective recall management process. Learn more
BLOG 3 Types of Batch Technologies to Maximize Productivity and Profitability Productivity and profitability: Two words that are constantly at the forefront of every manufacturer’s mind. How can I make my operations, systems, and processes more productive and profitable? What new tools are available to help improve productivity and increase profitability? Learn more
BLOG The Evolution of MES: Why Honeywell’s New Manufacturing Excellence Platform Is a True Game-Changer for Pharmaceutical Manufacturing Manufacturing Excellence Platform takes the concept of a Pharma Manufacturing Execution System to a whole new level. Yes! It is that amazing Learn more
BLOG Honeywell’s Manufacturing Excellence Platform: Shaping the Future of Life Sciences Today Honeywell continues to push the boundaries with the recently launched Manufacturing Excellence Platform. As mentioned in our previous... Learn more