Three ways to assess your Quality Maturity June 8, 2020 Maturity matters—especially when it comes to your quality processes and systems Quality maturity plays a key role in both the FDA Center for Drug Evaluation and Research (CDER) Pharmaceutical Quality for the 21st Century initiative and the Center for Device and Radiological Health (CDRH) Case for Quality initiative. But how can a quality system be assessed for maturity? Here’s what we’ve discovered. What Does “Mature” Look Like?The overall maturity of your quality system depends on the maturity in each of three operational layers: Quality control Quality assurance Quality management In a mature quality system, each layer has clear, well-defined processes and responsibilities. Information and data move between layers in a rational, predetermined way, triggering cascading evaluations and actions. However, maturity in one layer can mask signs of trouble in another. Knowing which red flags indicate immaturity at each level can help you pinpoint and correct such problems Qualiy Control MaturityQuality control describes the steps that are taken to make sure that only product that complies with the approved/accepted specifications is released for subsequent use or processing. In a mature quality control program, you can: Consistently identify product that is nonconforming or out of spec. Quickly escalate captured quality data to quality assurance decision-makers Accurately determine both root cause and necessary corrective actions Identify any issues with equipment before they affect product quality Warning signs of an immature quality control program include: Failure to identify product quality issues before market impact Inconsistent classification of product quality issues Significant equipment failures that harm product quality and escape detection An unusual or unexpected distribution of complaints across batches, ranges or sites can indicate problems with process variation or process control. By comparing the Standard Deviation and Mean of Complaints per Batch for a product, insight into the suitability of process and product control can be ascertained. For example, the Standard Deviation being greater than the Mean would indicate some batches having complaint counts potential two, three, even 10 times the complaints count for other batches. That sort of complaint-by-batch distribution would suggest failure to identify nonconforming product prior to release —a sign of immature quality control—or allowing nonconforming product to be released—a hallmark of immature quality assurance. Quality Assurance MaturityQuality assurance not only supports and enables production operations but also handles and responds to quality control escalations. In a mature quality assurance program, Quality control issues are consistently addressed within risk classes. Reportable product quality issues are identified and promptly escalated, as needed. Quality control escalation is reported to the appropriate agency in a timely fashion. Investigations result in determination of a true root cause and actionable corrections. Immature quality assurance results in less-than-thorough investigations and misidentification of both root cause and appropriate corrections. Product quality issues result in variable outcomes and are under-reported to the responsible agency. To identify an immature quality assurance system, watch out for the following: Over-classification of records, which can suppress the identification of trends and relationships, leading to ineffective CAPA or repeating product quality issues. High rates of root causes related to “human” causes – User operator training, procedure incorrect or not followed and similar root cause categories may indicate inadequate training that doesn’t differentiate between qualified and unqualified personnel and doesn’t prevent unqualified personnel from handling product or making decisions. Frequent revision of procedures and other documents, which may suggest trial-and-error “development” of SOP, test methods, batch processing instructions and other reference documents. Rapid onboarding of new hires, with irregular training completion and per-day SOP read rates. Large volumes of Planned Deviations, a greater than expected ratio of processes with planned deviation (or temporary change control) compared to processes without planned deviation. Quality Management MaturityQuality management ensures that adequate resources are available for the production and control of quality product. Immaturity in quality control or assurance automatically indicates immature quality management, which is responsible for: Corporate compliance with regulatory requirements Enforcement of regulatory and internal requirements Directing operational decision-making and a corporate culture of quality Aside from signs of immaturity in quality control or assurance, how can you identify immature quality management? High rates of SCAR/SCAPA and for-cause audits and a low rate of supplier disqualification, indicating ongoing use of poor suppliers and introducing risk into the quality of materials components received and placing more strain on quality control. High variable rates of deviation, OOS, or complaints without coordinated corrective actions to improve enable substandard processes (both manufacturing and supportive) Slow or absent reaction to quality issues that warrant reporting and market action About the author Daniel Burns is a Director of Product Management. Dan brings a wide breadth of industry experience coupled with practical knowledge as an end user of TrackWise and TrackWise Digital. He is very knowledgeable of the current FDA, EMEA and Health Canada regulations regarding manufacturing operations, packaging operations, quality control, R&D, warehouse management and distribution practices. Share via: Twitter LinkedIn Facebook Email
BLOG The Evolution of MES: Why Honeywell’s New Manufacturing Excellence Platform Is a True Game-Changer for Pharmaceutical Manufacturing Manufacturing Excellence Platform takes the concept of a Pharma Manufacturing Execution System to a whole new level. Yes! It is that amazing Learn more
BLOG Honeywell’s Manufacturing Excellence Platform: Shaping the Future of Life Sciences Today Honeywell continues to push the boundaries with the recently launched Manufacturing Excellence Platform. As mentioned in our previous... Learn more
WHITE PAPER 99% Of Life Sciences Organizations Are Embracing AI. Are You? Life sciences organizations are enthusiastically embracing AI, but concerns over talent, skills, and data quality highlight the limitations of an in-house approach. Download this latest white paper to learn more. Learn more
EBOOK Accelerating Data-Driven Outcomes in Life Sciences Life sciences companies must adopt a strategic digital transformation approach, leveraging diverse data sources, data fabric, and dedicated business applications to remain competitive and agile. Download this Frost & Sullivan eBook to explore recent industry trends and how integrating data supports the progression toward Life Sciences 4.0 Learn more
ON-DEMAND Honeywell Electronic Logbooks With paper-based logging often leading to inefficiencies and compliance risks, it’s crucial to explore modern solutions. Watch our latest webcast, to see how the right e-Logbook can address these challenges and optimize your operations. Learn more
WEBINAR Using Batch Historian Technology to Accelerate Data-Driven Manufacturing Optimization Join our webinar to explore how Batch Historian technology can streamline data capture and reporting, enabling faster, informed decision-making. Register Now! Learn more
WEBINAR Revolutionizing Life Science Recalls Explore how the latest innovations in data fabric technology can revolutionize product recall management, ensuring future-ready, agile and effective recall processes. Learn more
EVENT 7th Annual European Medical Device & Diagnostic Quality Assurance and Regulatory Affairs Conference Unlock tomorrow's standards today by innovating, collaborating, and leading at the Quality Assurance and Regulatory Affairs Conference! Join leading Supplier Quality Management (SQM) and QA/QC professionals for 2 days of interactive sessions, expert discussions, and networking opportunities aimed at advancing regulatory compliance and minimizing quality risks in the medical device industry. We are Bronze Sponsors of the 2024 Medical Device QA & SQM Conference, Belgium. Learn more
WEBINAR Discover How Gedeon Richter Transformed Their Quality Management Hear how leading European Pharmaceutical and Biotech company Gedeon Richter successfully implemented a digital quality management system to support their business goals and patient-centric mission. Learn more
WEBINAR AI-Driven Innovation: Redefining Quality Management in Life Sciences Take a deep dive into the confluence of AI and life sciences, exploring how artificial intelligence is poised to revolutionize the realm of quality management in the sector. Learn more
EVENT Honeywell Life Sciences Innovation Days Honeywell invites you to join us for one of our Life Sciences Innovation Days, a series offered throughout the globe in 2024. We will present a variety of process innovations to support the digital transformation of life sciences manufacturing. Themes will include orchestrating systems and data, preventing and containing cyber incidents, quality control and management, modular automation, and the Honeywell life sciences roadmap. Discussion will address streamlining manufacturing, creating batch records, and fulfilling regulatory reporting requirements. Learn more
EVENT Pharma Manufacturing World Summit Join us at Pharma Manufacturing World Summit on May 14, 2024 where Honeywell's Zillery Fortner will be co-presenting on "The Value of a Unified Life Sciences Solution in Pharma 4.0." Learn more
EVENT TUG Europe Join industry peers at one of these FREE events for TrackWise and TrackWise Digital customers, with two dates and locations to choose from. Enjoy a networking at our pre-event receptions, as we celebrate 30 years of TrackWise! Take advantage of a FREE TrackWise Digital pre-event training workshop. Learn more
EVENT RQA 2024: International QA Conference With diverse industry representation including regulatory authorities like the MHRA, it’s a hotspot for those in GCP, GLP, GMP, pharmacovigilance, and more. The conference has evolved to cover a wider scope, offering unparalleled networking opportunities across three dynamic days for delegates, sponsors, and exhibitors to engage on pivotal industry topics. Register to attend this insightful event where you can hear our Industry Business Development Director, Fabrizio Mangilio deliver one of this year's RQA 2024 keynote sessions. We are Platinum Sponsors of the RQA 2024: International QA Conference Learn more
EBOOK 5 Things to Know About EUDAMED EUDAMED (European database for medical devices) is a centralized database that aims to enhance the transparency and traceability of medical devices in the EU. Learn more